Self-Assessment Report 2022-23 - page 2

How we measured progress:

Indicator 1:

4 replacement play parks completed by March 2023, at:

  • Ballymena Road Ahoghill
  • Martinstown
  • Ferris Park Larne, and
  • Woodburn Carrickfergus

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

  • Ferris Park in Larne officially opened on 9 June, and Woodburn in Carrickfergus on 15 June 2023.
  • Works at Ahoghill and Martinstown Play Parks completed on 7 July 2023. Delays were experienced at both sites due to significant weather events.

Indicator 2:

3 new or upgraded Multi-Use Games or kick-about areas completed by March 2023, at:

  • Portglenone
  • Carnlough
  • Glynn

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

The status of each Multi-Use Games Area or kick-about area is as follows:

Portglenone: A smaller design option was approved at committee in June 2023. Detailed design and contractor procurement will now progress.

Glynn: The planning application for the Glynn kick-about went to July Planning committee for approval. Detailed design and contractor procurement will now progress.

Carnlough: Detailed design and contractor procurement is being progressed.

Indicator 3:

A minimum of 5 outdoor-safety training courses delivered by March 2023.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

Five courses were delivered by 31 May 2023.

Indicator 4:

A minimum of 50 participants across the 5 programmes.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

152 people participated across the 5 programmes.

Improvement Objective 4: Improving Infrastructure to encourage electric vehicle uptake in the borough to reduce emissions and protect the environment for future generations.

Why we did this:

  • The UK Government announced the year 2030 as the phase-out date for the sale of new petrol and diesel cars and vans. From 2035, all new cars and vans must be fully zero emission at the tailpipe.
  • Improving the borough's electric vehicle infrastructure will facilitate a sustainable transition to low-carbon transport systems.
  • In a survey conducted to establish attitudes and behaviour towards transport use, almost 30% of Northern Ireland respondents (from a total of 464) were from Mid and East Antrim (equating to 134 people). Of these, 34% of respondents who plan to change their vehicle in the next three years said they would be likely to purchase a battery electric vehicle. (Source: Survey conducted in July 2021 as part of the FASTER project, in conjunction with Transport Research Partners).

Who was responsible: The Director of Operations

What you see:

Outcome 1:

A target of 3 rapid electric vehicle chargers (50kW, 80% charge in 20 minutes) installed at strategic locations in the Borough by December 2023, as part of the cross-border FASTER project.

(Project timescales were extended and targets updated after the consultation period).

Status:

Stopped.

How did we do this year?

Due to changes in delivery, by the project lead, it was no longer viable, financially, or environmentally, for Mid and East Antrim Borough Council to remain a partner in this project. Therefore, this measure has been deemed as ‘stopped’, and will not be taken forward by the Council.

It does not form part of the Performance Improvement Plan for 2023/24.

Outcome 2:

A minimum of 12 fast chargers (22kW, charge in 1 to 2 hours) installed throughout the Council area by September 2023, as part of the On-street Residential Chargepoint Scheme.

 

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

12 fast chargers are secured for the Borough. Completion is now expected by March 2024, following a delay in the tendering process.

This outcome forms part of the Performance Improvement Plan 2023/24 Improvement Objectives.

Outcome 3:

A communications and awareness campaign to influence behavioural change towards electric vehicle use.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

As part of the communications campaign for the FASTER project, South West College delivered a series of EV Talk webinars, hosted by Dr Euan McTurk. These were promoted on social media for our residents.

One webinar was held in November 2022, and a second in December 2022. These were attended by 3

How we measured progress:

Indicator 1:

3 rapid chargers installed at key strategic locations by December 2023.

 

Status:

Stopped.

How did we do this year?

This project is not being taken forward by Mid and East Antrim Borough Council.

Indicator 2:

A minimum of 12 fast chargers installed throughout the Borough by September 2023.

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

The chargers are now expected to be installed by March 2024.

Indicator 3:

A public survey conducted to examine any changes in attitude and behaviour towards transport use by December 2023.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

Two surveys were completed:

  • One in July 2021, which surveyed 1,775 people.
  • A second in July 2022, which surveyed 1,485 people.

Key findings showed:

  • 82% of respondents felt their awareness of electric vehicles had improved in the last 12 months.
  • 54% of respondents in the 2022 survey stated they were likely to choose a battery EV as their next car, compared to 52% in the 2021 survey.
  • The top two concerns of electric vehicle ownership changed from range activity and purchase cost in 2021, to purchase cost and public charging infrastructure in 2022.

Improvement Objective 5: Creating an Autism Friendly Mid and East Antrim Borough Council.

Why we did this:

  • Autism is a developmental disability that influences a person’s ability to communicate and relate to other people, as well as affecting how they make sense of the world. It is a spectrum condition, meaning that while all people with autism will have similar problems, overall, their condition will impact them in different ways. Some people may be able to lead independent lives, while others will require a lifetime of specialist support. (Source: “Prevalence of Autism (including Asperger Syndrome) in School Age Children in Northern Ireland” Department of Health and NISRA (2023).
  • Figures extracted from the 2022/23 Northern Ireland School Census show that 15,212 school aged children had been diagnosed with autism. This represents an estimated autism prevalence rate of 5.0% within the school aged population.  (Source: “Prevalence of Autism (including Asperger Syndrome) in School Age Children in Northern Ireland” Department of Health and NISRA (2023).
  • Improving people's health and wellbeing, and reducing health inequalities, is one of residents' top five priorities for making the local area a good place to live. (Source: Mid and East Antrim Borough Council Household Survey, 2018).

Who was responsible: The Director of Community.

What you see:

Outcome 1:

The continued rollout of an awareness raising programme.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

Seven workshops were delivered during 2022/23.

Autism-Friendly Information Roadshows were held in Carrickfergus in January 2023 and Ballymena in February 2023. The Larne Roadshow was postponed due to the unavailability of key organisations and took place in June 2023.

Four online Makaton taster sessions, a unique language programme that uses symbols, signs, and speech to enable people to communicate, took place in March 2023, and a further two in April. We have a waiting list of 142 people registered for this training.

We co-hosted a free exhibition entitled ‘Creative Voices: What Autism Means to Me’, alongside the Education Authority Autism Advisory and Intervention Service. The exhibition displayed over 100 pieces of artwork by autistic post-primary pupils from across Northern Ireland.

We highlighted Autism Acceptance Week by creating a screen saver for our intranet and issued an article to staff about the work of the initiative.

The launch of Top Tips for Business will take place in 2023/24.

This objective and related outcomes and key performance indicators are included within the Performance Improvement Plan for 2023/24.

Outcome 2:

Additional Council venues becoming ‘Autism Friendly’ places.

(This is a deviation from the Consultation Document, where internal action plans are to be delivered, rather than external formal recognition).

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

Though later than anticipated, four Council venues are expected to complete their ‘Autism-Friendly’ action plans by September 2023.

Outcome 3:

Additional Council staff recognised as Autism Champions, to advocate on behalf of individuals with autism within Council venues and events.

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

We expect to have four additional Autism Champions within Council by September 2023.

Outcome 4:

The continued rollout of Just A Minute Awareness Training to Council staff.

 

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

103 staff members took part in the training by 31 March 2023.

How we measured progress:

Indicator 1:

4 additional ‘Autism Friendly’, virtual or in-person, public awareness sessions held for businesses, Council staff or the local community by March 2023.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

Seven autism-awareness sessions were held over 2022/23.

Indicator 2:

At least 90% of attendees reporting that their knowledge of autism increased following the training sessions.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

100% of participants reported their knowledge of autism increased following the training.

Indicator 3:

Autism-Friendly action plans delivered in 3 Council venues by March 2023.

 

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

The Braid Museum and Arts Centre, and Larne Arts Centre received Autism Impact Award training in March 2023.

Carrickfergus Museum and Andrew Jackson Cottage received their formal training on 5 June 2023.

All four venues are aiming to complete their action plans for formal accreditation by September 2023.

This target is included within the Performance Improvement Plan for 2023/24.

 

Indicator 4:

6 additional Council staff recognised as Autism Champions by March 2023.

Status:

Not achieved.

How did we do this year?

The delivery mechanism limits the Council to having one official Champion per venue. Venue staff will receive the training, but not the formal accreditation.

We anticipate having four additional Autism Champions by September 2023, as outlined in the Performance Improvement Plan for 2023/24.

The original target cannot be achieved.

Indicator 5:

An additional 100 Council staff completing Just A Minute awareness training by March 2023.

 

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

103 additional Council staff completed the training.

Improvement Objective 6: Improving customer engagement and service delivery by enhancing the Council's use of information technology.

Why we did this:

  • Our services will be more effective and efficient, providing greater satisfaction and value for money for ratepayers.
  • Digital transformation will lead to improved management reporting and will support better and more informed decision-making.
  • The COVID-19 pandemic has emphasised the need for greater flexibility in delivering online services. ICT can be used as a driving tool to minimise face-to-face scenarios and help ensure our services are more accessible.
  • 39% of residents said they would like to be able to report a problem online, 37% would like to book activities, 27% would like to buy tickets, and 22% would like to pay bills (Source: Mid and East Antrim Household Survey, 2018).

Who was responsible: The Interim Director of Corporate Services

What you see:

Outcome 1:

A redesign of the Council’s website, developed from user experience feedback (Phase 3).

Status:

Not achieved.

How did we do this year?

The Council is developing a Customer-First approach, and the website will be considered as part of that workstream.

Updates will continue within the Performance Improvement Plan 2023/24 quarterly updates, as appropriate.

Outcome 2:

An expansion of the automated customer call system into an additional service area.

Status:

Not achieved.

How did we do this year?

The Council is developing a Customer-First approach, and the call centre will be considered as part of that workstream.

Updates will continue within the Performance Improvement Plan 2023/24 quarterly updates, as appropriate.

Outcome 3:

The implementation of the new Northern Ireland Planning Portal for Mid and East Antrim.

Status:

Achieved.

How did we do this year?

The new Planning system went live on 5 December 2022, with 100% of applications now processed via the portal.

Outcome 4:

The digital transformation of at least one customer- facing service.

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

As of March 2023, full fibre was installed in all Council community centres.

Internet connectivity will not take place until the individual requirements of each community centre are established. The outcome will be a fully digital booking system within some of the council-managed centres (maximum total 16).

The timeline for completion is 30 September 2023.

This outcome is included within the Performance Improvement Plan for 2023/24.

How we measured progress:

Indicator 1:

A minimum of 4 digital projects completed by March 2023.

 

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

How did we do this year?

One digital project completed by March 2023; another is expected to complete by September 2023.

Two will be considered within the Customer-First workstream.


Previous years’ Improvement Objectives

It is important we continue to report on our previous Improvement Objectives, where targets may not have been reached within the intended timeframe. Updates were provided on these objectives throughout 2022/23, within our quarterly reports.

Most of our previous objectives are considered either complete or business as usual, except for those noted here. We will continue to provide updates within the normal reporting schedule for the Performance Improvement Plan 2023/24, as appropriate.

Where possible, ongoing, or outstanding indicators from the Performance Improvement Plan 2022/23 are included within the Improvement Objectives for 2023/24.

Objective 1: The development of Sullatober Household Recycling Centre.

Outcome 1

A larger site with improved infrastructure and accessibility to maximise re-use and recycling.

Measure 1:

A 6,500m2 site by 31 March 2022.

Status:

Achieved.

The new recycling centre opened in May 2022.

Measure 2:

Increase the recycling rate by 23.2% by 31 March 2023.

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

There was a 12% increase in the rate of recycling to 72%. The site is still deemed to be in the settling-in stage, having just opened in May 2022. This target will remain until March 2024.

Measure 3:

1,046 additional tonnes of recycled materials by 31 March 2023.

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

A total of 940 tonnes was achieved due to the initial settling in period. This target will remain until March 2024.

Measure 4:

12 additional tonnes of reused materials by 31 March 2023.

 

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

Eight tonnes were achieved due to the initial settling in period. This target will remain until March 2024.

Outcome 2:

Financial savings by compacting waste and reducing fuel consumption.

Measure 1:

50% reduction in containers hauled per newly compacted material by 31 March 2023.

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

20% was achieved. This target will remain until March 2024.

Measure 2:

Reduce tCO2e by 800 by 31 March 2023.

 

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

287 tonnes were achieved due to the initial settling in period. This target will remain until March 2024.

Outcome 3:

A more effective and efficient service with increased customer satisfaction and value for money for ratepayers.

Measure 1:

Increased rate of customer satisfaction.

 

Status:

Achieved.

Customer satisfaction surveys conducted in 2021 and 2022 indicate an increase in satisfaction for accessibility, movement around the site, and sufficient site size.

Objective 2: Encourage people to value our natural environment through the promotion of the Green Dog Walkers Scheme.

Outcome 1:

A cleaner borough.

Measure 1:

A reduction in the number of residents perceiving dog foul to be an issue in our local areas.

Status:

Delayed but progressing.

In 2022, 42% of our Citizen Survey respondents said they see dog foul often, compared with 11% of respondents in 2018.  Our Officers will continue to promote the initiative across the borough and engage with residents and community groups to encourage responsible ownership.

 


Statutory key performance indicators

The Local Government (Performance Indicators and Standards) Order (Northern Ireland) 2015 sets statutory indicators and standards for councils.

The Department for the Economy, the Department for Infrastructure and the Department for Agriculture, Environment and Rural Affairs collate this information and publish the results.

We also publish this information on our website at: www.midandeastantrim.gov.uk/performance

Indicator 1: The average processing time of major planning applications.

Target: 

A maximum of 30 weeks.

Annual result 2022/23:

47.6 weeks

Status:

Not achieved.

Indicator 2: The average processing time of local planning applications.

Target:

A maximum of 15 weeks.

Annual result 2022/23:

8.6 weeks.

Status:

Achieved.

Indicator 3: The percentage of enforcement cases concluded within 39 weeks.

Target:

A minimum of 70%.

Interim result April to September 2022:

91.2%

Status:

Achieved.

Indicator 4: The number of jobs promoted through business start-up activity.

Target:

A minimum of 85 jobs.

Annual result 2022/23:

124 jobs. 

Status:

Achieved.

Indicator 5: The percentage of household waste collected by district councils that is sent for recycling.

Target:

At least 50%.

Annual result 2022/23:

51.4%

Status:

Achieved.

Indicator 6: The amount of biodegradable Local Authority Collected Municipal Waste that is landfilled.

Target:

A maximum of 16,387 tonnes.

Annual result 2022/23:

14,599 tonnes.

Status:

Achieved.

Indicator 7: The amount (tonnage) of Local Authority Collected Municipal Waste arisings.

Target:

The Department for Communities requires that Council sets and monitors its own individual target annually. There is no statutory target set for this indicator.

Annual result 2022/23:

73,433 tonnes.

Status:

Achieved.

Please note, the final waste management figures for 2022/23 will be audited and publicly released by the Northern Ireland Environment Agency by December 2023.

The remainder of this section reviews the statutory indicators in more detail.

Economic Development Indicator

From April 2022 to March 2023, 124 jobs were promoted through business start-up activity, 46% over the current target of 85, up 14% on last year, and similar to pre-pandemic levels.

We were the top performing Council in Northern Ireland in 2022/23 and have exceeded the target every year since 2015/16.

Our performance is presented in detail below.

Table 1: The number of jobs promoted through business start-up activity - Mid and East Antrim Borough Council (summary trend and comparative analysis).

Annual standard: 85 jobs promoted.

Past results

2018/19:

124

2019/20:

122

2020/21:

94

2021/22:

109

2022/23

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council result:

124 jobs promoted (146% against the standard).

 

Status and trend:

Standard achieved. Significant improvement on 2021/22 result.

 

Northern Ireland council average:

57.8 weeks.

Mid and East Antrim comparative council position:

Number 1

Table 2: The number of jobs promoted through business start-up activity - Mid and East Antrim Borough Council (annual results).

Annual standard:

85

2015/16

148

2016/17

193

2017/18

140

2018/19

124

2019/20

122

2020/21

94

2021/22

109

2022/23

124

Table 3: The number of jobs promoted through business start-up activity - Northern Ireland councils (2022/23).

Newry, Mourne and Down District Council

Standard:

155

Achieved:

187

Mid Ulster District Council

Standard:

210

Achieved:

169

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council

Standard:

85

Achieved:

124

Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council

Standard:

85

Achieved:

113

Fermanagh and Omagh District Council

Standard:

170

Achieved:

186

Derry City and Strabane District Council

Standard:

140

Achieved:

150

Causeway Coast and Glens Borough Council

Standard:

125

Achieved:

131

Belfast City Council

Standard:

325

Achieved:

293

Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon Borough Council

Standard:

165

Achieved:

216

Ards and North Down Borough Council

Standard:

85

Achieved:

101

Antrim and Newtownabbey Borough Council

Standard:

80

Achieved:

106

Planning Indicators

The Department for Infrastructure has published annual data for two of the three statutory planning indicators for the period April 2022 to March 2023. During this time, we remained within the statutory standard set for one indicator. Official data is only available for the first six months of the year for enforcement conclusion times.

Our performance against the three indicators is presented in detail below.

Table 1: Mid and East Antrim Borough Council planning results (summary trend and comparative analysis).

Indicator: The average processing time of major planning applications.

Standard: Less than 30 weeks.

Past results

2018/19:

43.2 weeks

2019/20:

42.4 weeks

2020/21:

39.2 weeks

2021/22:

34.7 weeks

2022/23

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council result:

47.6 weeks

Status and trend:

Standard not achieved.

Performance decline from 2021/22.

Northern Ireland council average:

57.8 weeks

Mid and East Antrim comparative council position:

Number 3

 

Indicator: The average processing time of local planning applications.

Standard: Less than 15 weeks.

Past results

2018/19:

7.8 weeks

2019/20:

7.6 weeks

2020/21:

10.4 weeks

2021/22:

9.6 weeks

2022/23

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council result:

8.6 weeks

Status and trend:

Standard achieved. Improvement on 2021/22 performance.

Northern Ireland council average:

19 weeks

Mid and East Antrim comparative council position:

Number 1

 

Indicator: Percentage of enforcement cases concluded within 39 weeks.

Standard: Greater than 70%.

Past results

2018/19:

88.2%

2019/20:

89%

2020/21:

82.6%

2021/22:

90.5%

2022/23 (Interim result for April to September 2022)

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council result:

91.2%

Status and trend:

Standard achieved. Similar performance to 2021/22.

Northern Ireland council average:

73.4%

Mid and East Antrim comparative council position:

Number 1

Planning indicator 1: The average processing time of major planning applications

  • At 47.6 weeks, we were within the top three performing councils in Northern Ireland in 2022/23. The shortest average processing time achieved was 46.4 weeks, followed closely by 47 weeks.
  • No council met the 30 week standard last year, with an average processing time among the eleven councils of 57.8 weeks. This represents an increase of 8 weeks compared with the previous financial year and exceeds the 30 week target by almost 28 weeks.
  • Six councils reported an increase in average processing times in 2022/23 compared with 2021/22, with five councils reporting a decrease. We experienced an increase of almost 13 weeks.
  • Major planning applications require approval from multiple statutory consultees, including but not limited to, the Rivers Agency, the Northern Ireland Environment Agency, and Transport NI. There are occasions when consultees are unable to provide feedback within the allocated timeframe, which can delay the approval process. Delays can also happen when applications have inaccurate or insufficient detail. On resolution, the application must go through the consultation process again.
  • The Department for Infrastructure annual bulletin identified significant events during the last two years that will have impacted on planning activity and processing performance. These include:
    • The coronavirus pandemic, with varying restrictions in place until February 2022.
    • The accessibility of the system for some users during January and February 2022.
    • A significant change in IT planning systems, with the development and implementation of two new planning systems in June and December 2022.

These factors should be kept in mind when interpreting and making comparisons with other time periods.

Table 2: Major development average processing times – Mid and East Antrim Borough Council (annual results).

Annual standard:

Less than 30 weeks

2015/16

36.8 weeks

2016/17

67.9 weeks

2017/18

29.0 weeks

2018/19

43.2 weeks

2019/20

42.4 weeks

2020/21

39.2 weeks

2021/22

34.7 weeks

2022/23

47.6 weeks

Table 3: Major Development average processing times - All Northern Ireland councils (2021/22 and 2022/23).

Annual standard:

Less than 30 weeks

Newry, Mourne and Down District Council

2021-2022:

44.3 weeks

2022-2023:

89.0 weeks

Mid Ulster District Council

2021-2022:

88.0 weeks

2022-2023:

68.1 weeks

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council

2021-2022:

34.7 weeks

2022-2023:

47.6 weeks

Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council

2021-2022:

106.8 weeks

2022-2023:

87.2 weeks

Fermanagh and Omagh District Council

2021-2022:

110.2 weeks

2022-2023:

64.0 weeks

Derry City and Strabane District Council

2021-2022:

51.6 weeks

2022-2023:

78.0 weeks

Causeway Coast and Glens Borough Council

2021-2022:

54.6 weeks

2022-2023:

46.4 weeks

Belfast City Council

2021-2022:

31.0 weeks

2022-2023:

57.2 weeks

Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon Borough Council

2021-2022:

31.6 weeks

2022-2023:

47.0 weeks

Ards and North Down Borough Council

2021-2022:

110.8 weeks

2022-2023:

104.5 weeks

Antrim and Newtownabbey Borough Council

2021-2022:

25.1 weeks

2022-2023:

52.1 weeks

Indicator 2: The average processing time of local planning applications.

  • We were the top performing council in Northern Ireland for the processing time of local planning applications in 2022/23, achieving an average of 8.6 weeks against the 15 week standard.
  • We were one of three local councils to meet the standard during this period, with an average Northern Ireland council processing time of 19 weeks.
  • We have achieved the standard every year since 2015/16 and reduced our average processing time of local planning applications by one week in 2022/23, compared with the previous year.

Table 4: The average processing time for local planning applications – Mid and East Antrim Borough Council (annual results).

Annual standard:

Less than 15 weeks

2015/16

14.2 weeks

2016/17

9.0 weeks

2017/18

9.6 weeks

2018/19

7.8 weeks

2019/20

7.6 weeks

2020/21

10.4 weeks

2021/22

9.6 weeks

2022/23

8.6 weeks

Table 5: Local Development average processing times - By Northern Ireland council (2021/22 and 2022/23).

Annual standard:

Less than 15 weeks

Newry, Mourne and Down District Council

2021/22:

18.8 weeks

2022/23:

21.6 weeks

Mid Ulster District Council

2021/22:

16.6 weeks

2022/23:

21.6 weeks

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council

2021/22:

9.6 weeks

2022/23:

8.6 weeks

Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council

2021/22:

16.2 weeks

2022/23:

32.7 weeks

Fermanagh and Omagh District Council

2021/22:

15.6 weeks

2022/23:

13.0 weeks

Derry City and Strabane District Council

2021/22:

15.6 weeks

2022/23:

21.0 weeks

Causeway Coast and Glens Borough Council

2021/22:

18.8 weeks

2022/23:

21.2 weeks

Belfast City Council

2021/22:

17.0 weeks

2022/23:

19.8 weeks

Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon Borough Council

2021/22:

24.8 weeks

2022/23:

21.2 weeks

Ards and North Down Borough Council

2021/22:

22.4 weeks

2022/23:

19.9 weeks

Antrim and Newtownabbey Borough Council

2021/22:

13.2 weeks

2022/23:

13.4 weeks

Indicator 3: The average percentage of enforcement cases concluded within 39 weeks.

  • We were the top performing council in Northern Ireland for the percentage of enforcement cases progressed to target conclusion within 39 weeks over the period April to September 2022, achieving 91.2% against a target of 70%.
  • We have achieved this standard every year since 2015/16 and await the official publication of annual data for this indicator.

Table 6: Percentage of enforcement cases concluded within 39 weeks – Mid and East Antrim Borough Council (annual results).

Standard:

Greater than 70%

2015/16

85.9%

2016/17

88.1%

2017/18

86%

2018/19

88.2%

2019/20

89%

2020/21

82.6%

2021/22

90.5%

2022/23

91.2%

Table 7: Percentage of enforcement cases concluded within 39 weeks – By Northern Ireland council (April to September 2021 and 2022).

Newry, Mourne and Down District Council

2021/22:

51.1%

2022/23:

51.7%

Mid Ulster District Council

2021/22:

83.3%

2022/23:

51.6%

Mid and East Antrim Borough Council

2021/22:

90.9%

2022/23:

91.2%

Lisburn and Castlereagh City Council

2021/22:

86.8%

2022/23:

81.5%

Fermanagh and Omagh District Council

2021/22:

63.0%

2022/23:

73.8%

Derry City and Strabane District Council

2021/22:

76.6%

2022/23:

78.9%

Causeway Coast and Glens Borough Council

2021/22:

73.9%

2022/23:

68.0%

Belfast City Council

2021/22:

81.6%

2022/23:

85.7%

Armagh City, Banbridge and Craigavon Borough Council

2021/22:

81.7%

2022/23:

83.7%

Ards and North Down Borough Council

2021/22:

37.4%

2022/23:

50.8%

Antrim and Newtownabbey Borough Council

2021/22:

83.2%

2022/23:

87.4%

Continued on page 3...